Today I want to talk to you about positive affirmations. I often get asked what I think and feel about these, and I have to be honest at all times; it’s just who I am.
As a Deep Structure Mindset Coach, my work focuses on helping people understand what’s really going on in their belief systems, minds, hearts, and thoughts. Why? Because ultimately, they create our behaviours and outcomes. When it comes to positive affirmations, I don’t think the answer is quite as simple as many people would have you believe.
Now, before anyone panics, I am not saying that positive affirmations are bad, far from it. Positive affirmations are certainly better than telling yourself a bunch of lies based on thoughts and beliefs that were often formed when you were a child. If the alternative is constantly criticising yourself, doubting yourself, and reinforcing negative stories, then positive affirmations are definitely a step in a healthier direction.
However, here’s where I think we need to be careful. If you are repeating a load of words that you don’t instinctively believe, all you are really doing is lying to yourself again. Now, that can actually create more resistance rather than more confidence.
Do positive Affirmations Always Work?

Quite simply, no.
Let me give you some examples.
I hear affirmations like:
- “I’ll be a millionaire by next year.”
- “I’ll be a size 10 by next year.”
- “I always stop eating when I’m full.”
- “I’m going to post on social media every day until I earn £10,000.”
They sound lovely, ambitious and positive. However, are they believable? That’s the question.
Because if you have absolutely no idea what feeling full is, then repeating “I always stop eating when I am full” isn’t likely to feel true.
Likewise, if you’ve barely managed to post consistently on social media for a week, then telling yourself you’ll post every day for the next year probably feels overwhelming rather than empowering.
Similarly, if the thought of earning £10,000 in your business sends you into fear, panic, self-doubt, and worries about whether you’re worthy of that level of success, then your mind isn’t going to suddenly accept that affirmation as fact.
Instead, it often does the opposite. Your brain argues with it. Every time you say it, another part of your mind says, “No, you won’t.”
That’s not empowerment, that’s internal conflict.
What Does Research Say About Positive Affirmations?
Interestingly, psychological research supports this idea.
Studies have shown that affirmations can be effective when aligned closely enough with a person’s existing beliefs and sense of self. However, when affirmations are too far removed from what someone currently believes, they can create discomfort and increase feelings of inadequacy.
Researchers have found that individuals with lower self-esteem sometimes feel worse after repeating extremely positive statements. This is because the affirmation highlights the gap between what they are saying and what they genuinely believe. This can lead to toxic positivity. (Learn more about toxic positivity here on the VeryWellMind website.)
In simple terms, if your mind completely rejects the statement, it won’t store it as a belief. Unfortunately, that’s exactly what Ii see happening with many people who come to me for coaching.
How Are Beliefs Really Formed?

If we don’t believe something, we don’t store it as a belief. Think about it:
If somebody said to me: “Vivienne, you’re lovely and slim, and you look about 20.” Well, I’m in my 50s, slimmer than I was, but still carrying a little extra weight. My brain is immediately going to say: “Oh really? I don’t think so.”
I wouldn’t treat that statement as true because it sits too far from my current belief system.
However, if someone said something close enough to what I already believed, my brain would be much more likely to accept it and add it to my existing evidence.
That’s how beliefs grow, and how confidence grows. That’s how certainty grows. We stack evidence. When we are passionate about something and we repeatedly experience success, we strengthen that belief over and over again. Every action becomes proof. Results become evidence. Every success reinforces the story we are telling ourselves. Eventually, that belief becomes incredibly powerful.
What’s the Difference Between Wishful Thinking and Genuine Belief?
Let me give you an example.
I post on social media pretty much every day. Sometimes multiple times a day. So if I say, “I am visible”, “I enjoy being visible”, “My visibility positively impacts my business”, those are positive affirmations for me because I genuinely believe them. I have evidence for them. I’ve lived them. I’ve experienced them. They feel true.
However, if I didn’t believe those statements and repeated them anyway, I’d simply be creating overwhelm, frustration, and disappointment. I’d be setting myself up to feel like I was failing before I’d even started. Now that’s one of the biggest dangers of poorly constructed positive affirmations. Unfortunately, they can become another stick we beat ourselves with.
When Positive Affirmations Become Self-Sabotage

Many people do not realise that unrealistic affirmations can become part of a much bigger self-sabotage pattern. When we create goals or affirmations that are completely detached from reality, we often trigger what I call the self-harm cycle.
I’ve shared this cycle many times with my mastermind clients, CLUB clients, and one-to-one coaching clients because understanding where you sit within it can be life-changing.
The cycle often starts with unrealistic expectations. We expect ourselves to suddenly become someone different. We want dramatic change overnight. We expect massive results without building the foundations first. Then, when we inevitably fail to meet those expectations, we experience disappointment.
Here’s how the cycle looks:
Disappointment creates self-criticism. Self-criticism damages confidence. Damaged confidence reduces action. Reduced action creates poor results. Poor results reinforce the belief that we are not capable.
Round and round the cycle goes.
Unfortunately, many positive affirmations unintentionally contribute to this process because they ask us to believe something that feels completely unattainable.
Create Real Positive Affirmations Instead.
So what should we do instead? Naturally, we need to create real affirmations. Create affirmations that stretch you slightly, whilst remaining believable. This is very similar to the SMART objectives many of us use when we work in corporate environments.
Goals need to be:
- Specific
- Measurable
- Achievable
- Relevant
- Time-bound
The most effective goals stretch us slightly beyond our comfort zone but don’t push us into complete disbelief. Learn more about SMART goals in business on the Forbes website here.
The same principle applies to positive affirmations. The affirmation should feel like a next step, not a giant leap. Keep your affirmations close to the truth.
A Better Way To Use Positive Affirmations In Business
Let’s go back to the example of becoming more visible in your business.
Ask yourself, “What is genuinely achievable right now?”, “What would be a slight stretch from that?”
If you’re currently posting on social media three times a week, then perhaps your affirmation becomes: “I consistently create valuable content four times a week that helps my clients”
Do you see? That’s believable. It’s achievable. It’s stretching you slightly, and because you can believe it, you are more likely to take action on it. Naturally, once that becomes your reality, you create another next-level affirmation. Perhaps, for example, “I confidently show up five times a week and share valuable insights that help my audience.”
Then perhaps you add live videos. Then maybe speaking engagements. You may then target larger audiences. Each step builds upon the last, creates evidence, and strengthens belief.
The Power of Incremental Growth

I’m all about helping people find their next level. Not someone else’s level, nor the level they think they should be at, nor the level social media tells them they need to be at. Their next level. Because sustainable growth happens one believable step at a time.
When you move from where you are now to the next achievable level, something powerful happens. You start keeping promises to yourself. You begin to trust yourself and believe in yourself. Of course, when you believe in yourself, self-pride grows. Confidence grows. Momentum grows.
That is where real transformation happens. Not from repeating statements you don’t believe in, but from creating beliefs that are rooted in evidence, action, and achievable progress.
The Best Positive Affirmations Are The Ones You Believe
So, if there’s one thing I’d like you to take away from this article, it’s this:
The most effective positive affirmations are not necessarily the biggest, boldest, or most ambitious. They are the ones you genuinely believe in. The ones that feel possible and inspire you to take action. They do not create overwhelm.
Remember, every time you act in alignment with a believable affirmation, you collect evidence. Every piece of evidence strengthens the belief. That is how lasting confidence is built, how mindset shifts occur and how meaningful change happens.
I’d like you to do something. Before you repeat your next affirmation, ask yourself, “Do I actually believe this?” If the answer is no, don’t throw the affirmation away; simply adjust it to become believable. Make it your next level, rather than your impossible level.
Ready To Create Affirmations That Actually Work?
If you’ve realised that your current positive affirmations might be creating pressure, overwhelm, or unrealistic expectations, I’d love to help.
Together we can explore the beliefs that are really driving your behaviour, identify where you are getting stuck, and create next-level affirmations that feel authentic, believable and achievable. When your affirmations align with your belief system, they stop feeling like empty words and start becoming powerful catalysts for real change.
If you’d like support creating positive affirmations that genuinely work for you and your goals, get in touch. I’d be delighted to help you uncover the beliefs that are holding you back and build a mindset that supports the success you truly want.